Beware the Trolley Zealots
Keywords:Trolley problem, utilitarianism, bio-ethics, coronavirus, Covid-19, pastoral power, frames
AbstractThis essay draws on Mary Douglas' theory of institutional styles of thinking to analyze the debate about how and when the Coronavirus crisis can be brought to an end. The dominant approach, I show, frames the problem in utilitarian terms, akin to what is known among philosophers as "the trolley problem." I point out the pitfalls of this framing and contrast it with a counter-frame taken from the Judeo-Christian tradition of pastoral leadership. The lacunae of this institutional style of thinking are pointed out as well, in order to develop the critical distance necessary for a reasoned intervention in the crisis.
Agamben, G. (2020). Clarifications. An und für sich Blog, March 17. https://itself.blog/2020/03/17/giorgio-agamben-clarifications/ (last accessed April 20, 2020).
Baird, A. (2020). Trump Suggested Businesses Might Open Again Soon, Defying Public Health Experts. Buzzfeed News, March 23. https://www.buzzfeednews.com/article/addybaird/trump-open-business-soon-coronavirus-weeks (last accessed April 20, 2020).
Baker, M., & Fink, S. (2020). At the Top of the Covid-19 Curve, How Do Hospitals Decide Who Gets Treatment?. The New York Times, March 31. https://www.nytimes.com/2020/03/31/us/coronavirus-covid-triage-rationing-ventilators.html (last accessed April 20, 2020).
Baker, P., Kanno-Youngs, Z., & Rappeport, A. (2020). Torn Over Reopening Economy, Trump Says He Faces “Biggest Decision I’ve Ever Had to Make.” The New York Times, April 10. https://www.nytimes.com/2020/04/10/us/politics/coronavirus-trump-economy.html (last accessed April 20, 2020).
Bazelon, E. (2020). Restarting America Means People will Die. When Do We Do It? The New York Times Magazine, April 10. https://www.nytimes.com/2020/04/10/magazine/coronavirus-economy-debate.html (last accessed April 20, 2020).
Bleske-Rechek, A., Nelson, L.A., Baker, J.P., Remoker, M.W., & Brandt, S.J. (2010). Evolution and The Trolley Problem: People Save Five Over One Unless The One is Young, Genetically Related, or a Romantic Partner. Journal of Social, Evolutionary, and Cultural Psychology, 4(3), 115–127. http://dx.doi.org/10.1037/h0099295
Bogost, I. (2020). Enough with the Trolley Problem. The Atlantic, March 30. https://www.theatlantic.com/technology/archive/2018/03/got-99-problems-but-a-trolley-aint-one/556805/ (last accessed April 20, 2020).
Boltanski, L., & Thévenot, L. (2006). On Justification: Economies of Worth. Princeton, NJ: Princeton University Press.
Burnett, S., & Slodysko, B. (2020). “Liberate Michigan!” Right-Wing Coalitions Rallying to End Lockdown Restrictions amid Coronavirus Pandemic. Chicago Tribune, April 17. https://www.chicagotribune.com/coronavirus/ct-nw-coronavirus-protesters-trump-20200417-7oad7qhicrc53eywjaclwdsaoq-story.html (last accessed April 20, 2020).
Callon, M., Lascoumes, P., & Barthe, Y. (2009). Acting in an Uncertain World: An Essay on Technical Democracy. Cambridge, MA: The MIT Press.
Case, A., & Deaton, A. (2020). Deaths of Despair and the Future of Capitalism. Princeton, NJ: Princeton University Press.
Casselman, B. (2020). Worst Economy in a Decade. What Next? “Worst in a Lifetime.” The New York Times, April 29. https://www.nytimes.com/2020/04/29/business/economy/us-gdp.html (last accessed April 29, 2020).
Dave, P. (2020). Explainer: How Smartphone Apps Can Help “Contact Trace” the New Coronavirus. Reuters Technology News, April 14. https://www.reuters.com/article/us-health-coronavirus-tracing-apps-expla/explainer-how-smartphone-apps-can-help-contact-trace-the-new-coronavirus-idUSKCN21W2I8 (last accessed April 20, 2020).
Davis, S. (2020). “We Should Reward Them”: Senate Democrats to Push for Frontline Worker Hazard Pay. NPR, April 7. https://www.npr.org/sections/coronavirus-live-updates/2020/04/07/829007895/we-should-reward-them-senate-democrats-to-push-for-frontline-worker-hazard-pay (last accessed April 20, 2020).
Deleuze, G. (1992). Postscript on the Societies of Control. October, 59, 3–7. https://www.jstor.org/stable/778828
Douglas, M. (1990). How Institutions Think. Syracuse, NY: Syracuse University Press.
Emanuel, E.J., Persad, G., Upshur, R., Thome, B., Parker, M., Glickman, A., Zhang, C., Boyle, C., Smith, M., & Philips, J.P. (2020). Fair Allocation of Scarce Medical Resources in the Time of Covid-19. The New England Journal of Medicine, March 23. http://dx.doi.org/10.1056/NEJMsb2005114
Foot, P. (1967). The Problem of Abortion and the Doctrine of Double Effect. Oxford Review, 5, 5–15.
Foucault, M. (1981). Omnes et Singulatim: Towards a Criticism of Political Reason. In S. McMurrin (Ed.), The Tanner Lectures on Human Values, Vol. II (pp. 225–254). Slat Lake City, Utah: University of Utah Press.
Gebrekidan, S. (2020). For Autocrats, and Others, Coronavirus is a Chance to Grab Even More Power. The New York Times, March 30. https://www.nytimes.com/2020/03/30/world/europe/coronavirus-governments-power.html (last accessed April 20, 2020).
Goffman, E. (1974). Frame Analysis: An Essay on the Organization of Experience. New York: Harper & Row.
Griesbach, K. (2020). Positional Uncertainty: Seeking a Place in Unstable Times. PhD Dissertation. Department of Sociology, Columbia University.
Goychman, R. (2020). Intelligence Sub-Committee Confirms that the GSS will Continue to Track Citizens. The Marker, April 30. https://www.themarker.com/coronavirus/.premium-1.8808216 (last accessed April 30, 2020).
Hansen, S. (2020). The Great Depression Vs. Coronavirus Recession: 3 Metrics That Will Determine How Much Worse It Can Get. Forbes, March 24. https://www.forbes.com/sites/sarahhansen/2020/03/24/the-great-depression-vs-coronavirus-recession-3-metrics-that-will-determine-how-much-worse-it-can-get/#3147d67a15bd (last accessed April 20, 2020).
Ioannidis, J. (2020) A Fiasco in the Making? As the Coronavirus Pandemic Takes Hold, We Are Making Decisions Without Reliable Data. STAT Reports, March 17. https://www.statnews.com/2020/03/17/a-fiasco-in-the-making-as-the-coronavirus-pandemic-takes-hold-we-are-making-decisions-without-reliable-data/ (last accessed April 20, 2020).
Kabir, O. (2020). New Israeli Covid-19 Infection Ranking App Reminiscent of China’s Citizen Ranking System, Experts Say. Calcalist Tech, April 1. https://www.calcalistech.com/ctech/articles/0,7340,L-3805426,00.html (last accessed April 20, 2020).
Morath, E. & Chaney, S. (2020). U.S. Jobless Claims Top 20 Million Since Start of Shutdowns. The Wall Street Journal, April 16. https://www.wsj.com/articles/u-s-unemployment-claims-likely-continued-at-record-levels-11587029401 (last accessed April 20, 2020).
Navarrete, C.D., McDonald, M., Mott, M., & Asher, B. (2012). Virtual Morality: Emotion and Action in a Simulated 3-D “Trolley Problem”. Emotion, 12(2), 364–370. http://dx.doi.org/10.1037/a0025561
Porter, E., & Tankersley, J. (2020). Shutdown Spotlights Economic Cost of Saving Lives. The New York Times, March 24. https://www.nytimes.com/2020/03/24/business/economy/coronavirus-economy.html (last accessed April 20, 2020).
Proctor, K., Sample, I., & Oltermann, P. (2020). “Immunity Passports” Could Speed Up Return to Work After Covid-19. The Guardian, March 30. https://www.theguardian.com/world/2020/mar/30/immunity-passports-could-speed-up-return-to-work-after-covid-19 (last accessed April 20, 2020).
Pueyo, T. (2020). Coronavirus: How to Do Testing and Contact Tracing. Medium.com, April 28. https://medium.com/@tomaspueyo/coronavirus-how-to-do-testing-and-contact-tracing-bde85b64072e (last accessed April 30, 2020).
Robertson, C., & Gebeloff, R. (2020). How Millions of Women Became the Most Essential Workers in America. The New York Times, April 18. https://www.nytimes.com/2020/04/18/us/coronavirus-women-essential-workers.html (last accessed April 20, 2020).
Rodriguez, A. (2020). Texas’ Lieutenant Governor Suggests Grandparents Are Willing to Die for US Economy. USA Today, March 24. https://www.usatoday.com/story/news/nation/2020/03/24/covid-19-texas-official-suggests-elderly-willing-die-economy/2905990001/ (last accessed April 20, 2020).
Sonn, J.W. (2020). Coronavirus: South Korea’s Success in Controlling Disease Is Due to Its Acceptance of Surveillance. The Conversation, March 19. https://theconversation.com/coronavirus-south-koreas-success-in-controlling-disease-is-due-to-its-acceptance-of-surveillance-134068 (last accessed April 20, 2020).
Toynbee, P. (2020). Your Money or Your Life? Coronavirus has Sparked the Latest Culture War. The Guardian, April 7. https://www.theguardian.com/commentisfree/2020/apr/07/coronavirus-culture-war-lockdown-economy (last accessed April 20, 2020).
Velentino-DeVries, J., Singer, N., & Krolik, A. (2020). A Scramble for Virus Apps that Do No Harm. The New York Times, April 29. https://www.nytimes.com/2020/04/29/business/coronavirus-cellphone-apps-contact-tracing.html (last accessed April 30, 2020).
Wynne, B. (1992). Uncertainty and Environmental Learning: Reconceiving Science and Policy in the Preventive Paradigm. Global Environmental Change, 2(2), 111–127. https://doi.org/10.1016/0959-3780(92)90017-2
How to Cite
Copyright (c) 2020 Gil Eyal
The copyrights of all the texts on this journal belong to the respective authors without restrictions.
This journal is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution 4.0 International License (full legal code).
See also our Open Access Policy.